In the wake of Women’s History Month, it’s a good time to pause and reflect on the significance of our efforts to honor and uplift women. Amidst the flurry of acknowledgments and celebrations we see every March, there’s a deeper conversation to be had about how we support women on their professional journeys in higher education.
We know the numbers. The most recent edition of the American College President Study (ACPS) shows that the gender gap persists in higher education leadership. Though the number of women presidents has grown slightly (2.7 percent since 2017), they remain significantly outnumbered by men, 2:1. This disparity is even larger for women of color. Notably, as we think of how best to close this gap, women tend to have different career paths to the presidency compared to men, often rising through the academic ranks rather than coming in as external hires.
The leadership attribute continuum
In her 2018 book Leadership: In Turbulent Times, Doris Kearns Goodwin posits a number of questions: Are leaders born or made? Where does ambition come from? How does adversity affect the growth of leadership? Do the times make the leader or does the leader shape the times? How can a leader infuse a sense of purpose and meaning into people’s lives? What is the difference between power, title, and leadership? Is leadership possible without a purpose larger than personal ambition?
I believe that there are no definitive answers to questions that revolve around whether leaders are born or made, whether leadership is learned or innate, and what the qualities are of female leaders versus male leaders. Each of these answers is on a continuum and includes multiple perspectives. Successful leadership, and in this case leadership for women presidents, includes all of the above: leadership is both internal and also learned; leadership qualities vary by person and gender. However, there is a common denominator in the literature that asserts successful leaders embody and demonstrate some common attributes: humility, honesty, transparency, vulnerability, vision, and ethical behavior.
Leading initiatives and building relationships to lift others
One of my professional opportunities last year, following my 12-year presidency at the University of La Verne, was helping to lead an international initiative for the International Association of University Presidents (IAUP) that focused on strategic leadership skills for women university presidents, rectors, and chancellors. The initiative also dealt with how male and female presidents globally can create pathways, pipelines, and professional opportunities for women to ascend into executive leadership roles in higher education. Through this initiative, IAUP produced a publication spotlighting female international presidents and their pathways to the presidency, “Spotlighting Female Leadership: Strategies, Stories, Perspective.”
The authors in the publication talk often about a key ingredient for success: relationships. They emphasized the importance of mentors and peers, especially other women leaders, in their journey to the top. Essentially, they continually saw their role as moving an agenda that was not related to their own recognition or ego but rather, to the greater good.
They mentioned challenges like feeling lonely in the role and dealing with new leadership issues, which makes having mentorship networks crucial. Mentors, both men and women, played a big part in helping these women reach their goals. They also stressed the importance of having a diverse group of mentors and highlighted how peers and friends provided essential support. The message is clear: women in higher education leadership need each other. By building strong relationships, we can create a future where the presidency isn’t just attainable for women, but truly fulfilling.
Can we make it?
Based on ACPS data, ACE estimates that higher education would need to retain 500 women presidents and hire two times more women than men into the presidential role in the next five years to achieve gender parity. To achieve gender equity and be reflective of the current student population, 1,800 women presidents would need to be hired in the next four years.
Can we make it? I believe success largely hinges on those in power now. As presidents of higher education institutions throughout the United States and globally—both men and women—we have a duty to cultivate an environment where future female leaders can thrive. This means embodying the qualities of ethical, authentic, and humble leadership.
The Phoenix Philanthropy Group
The Phoenix Philanthropy Group partners with organizations and individuals to build the strategies and resources to optimize their impact on our global society. We do so by serving their needs with strategic, outcomes-driven revenue generation, constituent relations, strategic planning, and organizational development services that help our clients fulfill their missions and achieve their goals.
For more about Phoenix Philanthropy, see https://phoenixphilanthropy.com/about/ for other higher education leaders and aspiring female leaders.